What You Saw, What I Was Holding

What You Saw, What I Was Holding
What You Saw, What I Was Holding

Every life has two lists. We post one and carry the other.

Rory Callaghan · November 2026


Two lists

Every life has two lists.

One is the list we post. The other is the list we carry.

For five years, the first list was all most people saw. I want to show you the second one. Not to be pitied. Because I've come to believe the second list is where the truth lives, and almost all of us are carrying one in silence.

The question

Why do we hide what we're holding, and what changes when we finally show it?

The short answer

We hide what we're holding because hard moments tend to happen in private, while good ones get shared. So we compare our hidden list to everyone else's highlight reel and decide we're alone. Research shows we consistently underestimate how much others are struggling. Showing the second list breaks that illusion, for us and for the people watching.

On the surface

Here's what you saw.

  • SelfCare, published with my own money, became an Amazon bestseller
  • The 12 Medicines, a free layer of self-care for anyone who needs it
  • The CoCreator Incubator: two cohorts, fifty alumni, a community of 374
  • A co-creation venue model running across Grün, Intaaya, Tanam and Amar in Portugal
  • A 100-person summit, then a December retreat
  • Retreats in Bali, the Mentawais and Portugal
  • Online summits reaching every corner of the world
  • Mentoring clients through their own fires
  • Speaking, including a talk called Coherence before creation
  • Twenty-five thousand honest words written across 23 pieces
  • A vision for SelfCare Global, built on presence rather than proof

All of it true. All of it something I'm proud of.

Underneath

Here's what I was holding at the same time.

  • A pandemic, a relationship ending, and finding out I'd been cheated on
  • A year of my name being picked apart in rooms I wasn't in
  • Four months beside my mum while she told me, again and again, she didn't want to be here
  • Dad's diagnosis
  • Two years building a retreat centre with my own hands, then walking away with an empty bank account
  • A love that came close and pulled away, across 13,000 kilometres
  • One week where Dad died, an immigration fight began, the relationship ended, and a pothole put me in surgery
  • A funeral, and 25 relatives I was meeting for the first time
  • My mum's grief stacked on mine
  • My aunt choosing her own way to die
  • Nights I drank more than I wanted to, a week in bed, a tiredness sleep doesn't touch

Read the two lists side by side and they don't look like the same life. They are.

Why the second list stays hidden

I used to think I was hiding mine out of pride. Some of it was. But most of it was simpler than that.

The hard things happened in private. In a hospital corridor. On the floor of my mum's kitchen. In a car outside a lawyer's office. Nobody posts those rooms.

The good things happened in public. On stage. At the summit. On the beach at sunset with a hundred people.

So the world saw one list, and I started to believe that was the real one. That if I was building, I must be fine.

What the research shows

It turns out this isn't just my story. It's a well-documented pattern.

  • We think others are doing better than they are. In a set of four studies, Stanford and Berkeley researchers found people consistently underestimate how often others feel negative emotions and overestimate how often they feel positive ones. That held even for close peers. Part of the reason: people hide hard feelings more than good ones (Jordan, Monin, Dweck and colleagues, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2011).
  • That gap costs us. In the same research, the people who most underestimated others' struggles also felt lonelier, ruminated more and were less satisfied with life.
  • Naming it helps. James Pennebaker's research on expressive writing (Psychological Science, 1997) found that putting difficult experiences into words is linked to better health and wellbeing over time.

The French philosopher Montesquieu named it three centuries ago. If we only wanted to be happy, it would be easy. The trouble is we want to be happier than others, and we imagine them happier than they are.

The Two Lists practice

This is what I'd offer anyone carrying a hidden list. I call it the Two Lists practice.

  1. Write the surface list. Everything you've built, made, held together or achieved in the season you're in. Don't be modest.
  2. Write the underneath list. Everything you were carrying at the same time. Be honest. No one else has to see it.
  3. Read them side by side. Notice that both are true. Notice the first list was made while carrying the second.
  4. Share one line. With one person you trust. Not the whole list. One line.

That's it. The point isn't to perform pain. It's to stop living as if only half of you exists.

Where this doesn't apply

  • Not everything needs to be public. Sharing the second list with the world is a choice, not a duty. Some lines belong with a therapist, a friend or a journal, and that's enough.
  • Honesty isn't oversharing. Other people's stories live inside our lists too. I've left out names and details that aren't mine to tell.
  • Comparison works both ways. Someone else's hidden list may be heavier than yours. This isn't a contest. It's a reminder we're all carrying something.
  • If the list feels too heavy to hold alone, please speak to someone today. A doctor, a counsellor, a friend.

The shift

The day I wrote both lists down, something loosened.

I'd spent years thinking the first list was proof I was okay. It wasn't proof of anything except what I'd built while carrying the second.

I'm not ashamed of either list anymore. One shows what I made. The other shows what I made it through.

And I suspect if we all showed our second list, even once, we'd feel a lot less alone.

One action for today

Write your two lists. Ten minutes, pen and paper. Then read the second one slowly and put your hand on your chest.

Recap

  • Every life has two lists: the one we post and the one we carry.
  • Hard moments happen in private, so they stay hidden.
  • Research shows we underestimate how much others struggle, and that makes us lonelier.
  • Writing both lists down helps us see the whole truth.
  • Sharing one line with one person is enough to start.

Questions people ask

Why do people hide their struggles? Most hard experiences happen in private and bring up feelings we tend to suppress, while good moments are shared openly. Research by Jordan and colleagues (2011) found this leads people to underestimate how much others struggle.

Is it healthy to compare my life to others' highlight reels? It tends not to be. People who underestimate others' negative emotions report more loneliness and less life satisfaction. Remembering that everyone carries a hidden list makes comparison less sharp.

What is the Two Lists practice? A simple reflection: write what you built in a season, then what you were carrying at the same time. Read them side by side, then share one line with someone you trust.

Do I have to share my struggles publicly to heal? No. Writing privately or telling one trusted person can be enough. Pennebaker's expressive writing research suggests the benefit comes from putting experience into words, not from an audience.

What comes next in the series? Part 2, Invitations and Initiations, looks at the difference between what we choose and what we're asked to show up for.

A closing reflection

Both lists are mine. One shows what I built. The other shows what I built it through.

What's on your second list, and who could you show one line to this week?